|
|
|
Some hormone treatments increase cancer risks
Patricia Reaney 2005-04-29
Two types of hormone replacement therapies (HRT) increase a woman's risk of developing womb cancer, scientists said on Friday.
HRT, which replaces hormones diminished by menopause, is given as
oestrogen-only, combined oestrogen and progesterone or in some countries
as a synthetic steroid treatment known as tibolone. In a study of more
than a million women taking HRT, scientists found that patients using
oestrogen-only and tibolone had a higher risk of the cancer of the womb
than those not taking HRT. The dilemma is that oestrogen-only HRT
causes a greater increase in cancer of the endometrium (the lining of
the womb) but combined causes a greater increase in breast cancer,
Professor Valerie Beral, of the charity Cancer Research UK which
conducted the research, said. When you add them together, combined
causes a substantially greater increase in cancer than does oestrogen-only,
she added.
Women are prescribed HRT to relieve menopause symptoms such as hot
flushes, night sweats and mood swings. Tibolone, which is available in
Europe but not in the United States, is sold by Akzo Nobel unit Organon
as Liviala. Scientists have known about the raised risk of endometrial
cancer for some time, but the Million Women Study is the first to
compare the risk of both diseases in the same women. Since breast cancer is much more common than endometrial
cancer, combined HRT poses the greatest overall cancer risk, Beral
said, adding that not taking HRT is the best option to reduce the odds
of developing cancer.
The study, which is reported in The Lancet medical journal, showed that
around three out of every 100 women on combined HRT will develop either
breast or endometrial cancer over a five-year period, compared to 2,5
per 100 taking oestrogen-only HRT or tibolone and 1,5 per 100 not on any
of the drugs. Since the study began in the late 1990s, about 1 300 of
the women aged 50-64 years old have developed endometrial cancer and
more than 10 000 have suffered from breast cancer.
Overweight or obese women in the study had a greater risk of endometrial
cancer. Experts believe oestrogen stimulates the growth of cells in the
womb which can lead to cancer and obese women usually have higher level
of oestrogen in the blood. Most women who have not had a hysterectomy
are prescribed combined HRT or tibolone. In a commentary on the
research, Louise Brinton and researchers at the National Cancer
Institute in the United States said the main question is how to
prescribe hormones so women receive the biggest benefit and the least
risk.
To minimize cancer and other risks, clinicians should prescribe
the lowest possible dose of oestrogen for short periods of times,
said Brinton.
(Source: IOL, April 29, 2005)
|